This
course examines from the home health perspective what patient satisfaction is, how it differs from
patient experience, how it is determined, and
how to measure it.
Let's
start by reviewing our learning objectives.
Learning objectives are the groundwork for what
we are about to cover, and will help us to define
our goals for this program. This course will
only assume a very rudimentary knowledge of
patient satisfaction, as there are many
misconceptions about what it is and how it is
used.
Upon completion of this course you should
be able to:
1. Define
"patient satisfaction" and "patient experience" in
home health care.
2. Describe two
potential uses for patient satisfaction data in home
health care.
3. List two
characteristics of home health care patient
satisfaction measurement tools.
Background
In an
effort to progress from disease-centered care to
patient-centered care, new questions have to be
asked. As summed up by Valerie Billingham in the
Salzburg Seminar Session “Through the Patient’s
Eyes” this means “Nothing about me without me.”
In 1988,
the term “patient-centered care” was coined by the
Picker Institute
(then the Picker/Commonwealth Program for
Patient-Centered Care).
Further,
in the Institute of Medicine report “Crossing the
Quality Chasm”, patient-centered care was defined as
“care that is respectful of and responsive to
individual patient preferences, needs, and values”
and that assures “patient values guide all clinical
decisions.” This suggests moving from
provider-centered care to patient-centered care
where patients are actively engaged rather than
passive participants, innovative care delivery
strategies are developed beyond facility-based
visits, and the questions go beyond “What’s the
matter with you?” to include “What matters to you?”
Patient-Centered Care - “Nothing about
me without me.”
Patient Satisfaction
Patient Experience
|
|
Patient satisfaction surveys include the patient’s
own evaluation of their level of satisfaction with
services and systems.
This is
achieved through questions that may begin with, “How
satisfied are you with X” – X being the appointment
system, the caring and concern of the doctor, the
ease of access to medical care, or others. The
responses may range from strongly agree to strongly
disagree or from very good to poor. Patient
satisfaction responses may be used as an outcome
measure.
It has
been suggested that patient satisfaction is actually
a component or subset of patient experience. While
patient experience has been defined by the Beryl
Institute as “the sum of all interactions, shaped by
an organization’s culture, that influence patient
perceptions across the continuum of care.”(The
Beryl Institute, available at:
http://www.theberylinstitute.org/)
there are a variety of definitions in use for this
term. According to the Patient Experience Journal,
which debuted in 2014, the definition may include
occurrences and events, engagement of patients as
partners with individualized care, realization of
patient expectations, and the practice of
patient/family-centered care.
(Wolf JA, et al. Defining patient experience.
Patient Experience Journal. 2014;1(1):7-19.
Available at:
http://pxjournal.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1004&context=journal)
Definitions are as simply put as “how the patient
feels/felt (good or bad) as/after he or she
undergoes/underwent an episode of care”. More
complex definitions may define the variety of
components for expectations, from entrance to exit
of the healthcare experience. Specific examples may
include cleanliness, information about where to go,
convenient/punctual appointments, choice of hospital
and care providers, helpful staff, knowledge and
understandability of health care providers,
involvement in decision-making, reassurance and
advice about health care, information about causes
and management of health condition, and being given
an opportunity to discuss issues.
Patient experience surveys may rephrase questions
that are similar to patient satisfaction to
determine their experience for items,
such as
wait times, addressing patient concerns, and other
topics. These responses may quantify their
experience ranging from always to never or a
selection of specific options, such as 1 day to more
than 7 days. Patient experience ratings generally
have more to do with the interaction with clinicians
and others in the care system than outcomes.
It can be confusing because a patient may have a
negative outcome and still have a positive
experience
or may have a positive outcome with a negative
experience. Patient experience responses provide an
opportunity to learn how to address lower patient
satisfaction scores by providing specific experience
information. For instance, a low patient
satisfaction rating for a doctor’s caring and
concern may not identify a correction while an
experience response on an item, such as being
treated with courtesy and respect, may indicate
where an improvement can be made.
Interestingly, some contend that patient experience
measures may be more reliable than patient
satisfaction measures. For instance, there may be
several pitfalls in patient satisfaction results,
including the lack of a link between patient
satisfaction improvement and quality of care
improvement and a lack of a universally accepted
definition or measure to make a comparison.